Reparations for Who?

Ok so today’s Huffington Post contains an article about Obama’s opposition to slave reparations

On its face, reparations to ancestors of slaves sounds like a great idea… slavery was obviously a terribly embarrassing blemish in this country’s not-too-distant past, a mistake from which we are still suffering the consequences of… but at the same time, it’s…

Implausible.

It’s not realistic to expect we can make reparations to individuals, as some people currently support. It has been estimated that from the start of slavery through its abolition in 1865, black people contributed over 100 trillion dollars worth of unpaid labor. Who’s going to help us foot that bill? The UK? The Spaniards? The US wasn’t even a country until 1776, but slavery was alive and well way prior to that time.

Even if we were to do something like this, who would be eligible for the compensation?

I know plenty of white people who have at least one black ancestor tucked away in their family tree… during slavery it was extremely common for white plantation owners to sleep- and procreate- with black slave women. Southern states even passed laws with this in mind, and many states still have them on record. It’s because of such laws that my race of record is white. My father is black, my mother is white, but the laws dictate that a child’s race is that of their mother. This way white plantation owners could father children with black slave women, and the children born as a result would still be considered slaves.

How could we possibly apply the reparations fairly? Would people who could prove a certain percentage of black-blood get a higher compensation than those whose race is mixed? Do families who have not blended over the years, who have remained all black, get more money than those families that didn’t?

How does one measure racism from the past, or the destruction it caused?  We can’t look at a living person’s experiences from today to determine their compensation amount- otherwise we aren’t paying reparations for slavery, we’re paying reparations for the injustices suffered by the current generation. If that’s the case, damn near everyone would be entitled to a piece of the pie- or at the very least, just about anybody could make a good case for being eligible. Slave owners didn’t necessarily keep pristine records with regards to who fathered whose child. They were treated as animals, and very often, little effort was made to preserve their family trees. 

What about those black families whose ancestors managed to largely escape slavery by seeking freedom in the north, or settling farther out west? They suffered terribly, and their lives were often endangered because of their race… but because they weren’t slaves, are they entitled to any of this money?

We’d have to create a sliding scale of who deserves what, based on their family’s history… which I believe would be difficult to prove and ultimately would do nothing but further drive the racial wedge between us.

Many people make the mistake of comparing slave reparations to jewish reparations. Some argue that because some Jews received reparations, blacks should as well.

Slave reparations is not the same thing as reparations for concentration camp victims. There are still survivors of concentration camps alive today, and it isn’t too hard to go backwards and figure out who did and did not suffer as a result of Adolf Hitler and his regime. With slavery, it’s a little trickier than that. Slavery ended in 1865, so there isn’t anyone living today who used to be a slave… hell, there isn’t anyone living whose parents used to be slaves either…

In addition to compensating concentration camp victims, we are also prosecuting those remaining officials who helped perpetrate the crimes to begin with. Unfortunately we can’t do that where slavery is concerned. I’m certain that by now, there are plenty of white people whose ancestors once owned slaves who are wonderful non-racist people today. Certainly we cannot hold them accountable for the sins of their distant relatives. Similary, we can’t just start handing cash out to every single black person and expect it to make a real difference.

Instead, Obama’s ideas seem to be the most realistic.

Rather than earmark a certain number of dollars for damn near every citizen of this country, let’s put more effort into those areas that still suffer the ill-effects of a slave-driven nation. There are plenty of school districts that would benefit from a little extra cash so that their predominantly poor- and black- students can have the same opportunities that the more wealthy white districts have.

In addition, let’s put more time and money into diversity training so that we can teach all people, regardless of their heritage, how to be more open and accepting of those who are different than they are. We should continue giving incentives to potential employers to diversify their ranks, wholeheartedly encouraging the hiring of qualified minority workers.

Taking those steps would be much more beneficial than giving every damn person with a good tan a few extra bucks in their pockets.

The racial mixture in this country is beautiful, and it would cause more harm than good to try and step back and figure out who-suffered-what-at-whose hands.

Forgiveness, and a renewed effort towards equality is the only thing that makes sense.

After all, money does not buy happiness…

It won’t buy equality either.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Reparations for Who?

  1. Really great post, I couldn’t have said it better myself. I really believe that if there were to be reparations it should be given to organizations rather than individuals. We need to work on ending the racism and prejudice that lingers in this country, rather than give random amounts of money to people.

  2. Thank you so much for weighing in! Reparations are indeed a touchy subject, but I agree with you. Certainly we have a responsibility to do something to end continuing racism… and definitely, in order to be effective we have to acknowledge the horrific events that occured during the slave trade. However, to hand a bunch of black people (hey- where do the mixed folks like me fall into the equation???) a bunch of cash and expect things to change is just naive.

  3. Awesome post! That’s as good a summation of the issue as I’ve ever seen. Politics and reparations for past harm are never clear cut – if only there was half so logical a solution to the problems with Australian Aborigines, which is still an ongoing issue.

  4. I guess it’s safe to say every country has its skeletons in the closet. I don’t think it’s a good idea to forget… but sometime amends are not an option and we all need forgive and move forward.

  5. Your comment is nothing more than the continuing excuse for a Government to not be responsible for what has been labeled by an International Body as a Criminal Act aginst a human people. In the later part of the 1800’s Callie House lead a Struggle for the Ex-Slave Reparations through her 400,000 member organization called the Ex-Slave Mutual Relief, Bounty and Pension Association. She was imprisoned. Also all Slave Descendants are not inflitrated biologically with white ancesstors. Use the same method to determine that was used to keep Slave Descendants from eating at WoolWorth lunch counters or even re-implement the paper bag test. Also where in Juriprudence does the guilty tell the court what the extent of their punishment will be. Only when it comes down to black African Slave Descendants does such nonscence surface once again. The US Government, present US Corporation and even the Catholic Church all benefited from the criminal enslavement of Black Africans and were unjustly enriched. Miscegenation and the creation of mulatos are all in the plan to disminish the point. Reparations NOW!

  6. Uhh… thanks for the comment, but I have never made excuses about why the government shouldn’t provide slave reparations. In fact, I am an advocate of reparations- just not for individuals. I haven’t heard one single argument that sounds even the slightest bit reasonable with regards to reparations for individuals. In fact, long as your comment was, and as big a supporter as you obviously are, even you didn’t come up with any solutions. We can sit here in cyberspace, or hell, hang out in a bar all day long talking about what “should” happen- but with no concrete ideas to bring to the table- only complaints- really, what are you contributing?

    Of course the government, corporations and the Catholic Church benefited from slave labor… and scores of others benefitted as well. Perhaps my post was too long for you to read in its entirety, but I actually stated that the amount of free labor the world has received from slaves tops $100 Trillion.

    Will the rest of the world contribute to paying this money back? After all, the U.S. certainly wasn’t a nation for the entire span of slavery… many other countries have blood on their hands as well.

    I fail to see what lining damn near every person in this country’s pockets with a few extra dollars (and make no mistake, almost every single person will be entitled to some amount of compensation- even many of the whitest of the whites have black blood dating from slavery in their pasts) will accomplish.

    Why are you so adamently opposed to instead giving money to poor black school districts, minority businesses, and incentives to potential employers to commit to a diverse work place? That would go much farther than receiving a check from Uncle Sam for next to no monetary value- just so you can have a nice shopping spree at Macy’s or wherever it is you chose to spend your stimulus check.

    I am not one of the guilty, sir, and my ancestors, as I can assume was the case with yours, were enslaved as well. I am not one of the so-called “guilty” who are dictating what their own punishment should be anymore than you are.

    I can wish upon a star for our nation to suddenly make our terrible past “right” again, but the fact remains that this is not reality. There is nothing anyone can do today that will truly make amends for the atrocities suffered in the past, nor is there anything other than forgiveness and a renewed commitment to equality that will make my daughters’ lives any easier than my ancestors lives were.

    If you have any reasonable ideas, solutions that can actually be implemented, I’d love to hear them.

    Until then, my stance remains unchanged.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s